When Eddie and the Cruisers came out in 1983
it was either ignored or received negatively by critics and performed poorly at
the box office. However, over the years it has quietly cultivated a small but
dedicated cult following. The film is primarily a mystery – what happened to
musician Eddie Wilson? – and it also an unabashed love letter to rock ‘n’ roll
and the New Jersey shore in the 1960s. It has been over 35 years since the film
was released and it is high time for a re-evaluation of this under-appreciated
gem.
Maggie
Foley (Ellen Barkin) is a journalist for Media
magazine and is doing a retrospective piece on Eddie and the Cruisers, a
New Jersey bar band that was a minor sensation in the 1960s with one hit record
and the top song in country during the summer of 1963. The band were working on
an ambitious follow-up when lead singer Eddie Wilson (Michael Pare) drove his
car off a pier and met with a watery demise on March 15, 1964. Or did he? No
body was found. Maggie’s hook is that maybe Eddie didn’t die. She draws a
parallel between him and French poet Arthur Rimbaud, who like Eddie, pulled a
disappearing act at the height of his popularity while striving for perfection
in his art. Now, everyone is looking for the master tapes of A Season in Hell, the album that was to
be Eddie’s magnum opus, and which also disappeared only a day after Eddie
vanished.
Through a
series of flashbacks from the surviving band members, we see the rise and fall
of Eddie and the Cruisers. The film is told predominantly from the point-of-view
of Frank “The Wordman” Ridgeway (Tom Berenger), the band’s piano player and
lyricist. He teaches English in high school now but Maggie’s questions bring
all the old memories flooding back. The first flashback takes us back to 1962,
while President John F. Kennedy was still in the White House, and when the
United States was still a relatively innocent and hopeful country. Eddie and
the Cruisers meet Frank at a bar in the Jersey Shore. Sal Amato (Matthew
Laurance), their bass player, has been writing their songs but they aren’t enough
for Eddie who tells him, “It just ain’t what I was looking for.” Eddie spots
Frank and asks him what he thinks. Frank impresses Eddie with his knowledge of
writing when he points out that Sal’s song needs a caesura, “a timely pause, a
kind of strategic silence.” This is pretty high-falootin’ stuff for a rock ‘n’
roll movie and an indicator that this film aspires to be something different.
Eddie
dreams of creating music that endures and director Martin Davidson juxtaposes
these almost wistful sentiments with Sal’s contemporary Cruisers revival that
is pure Las Vegas cheese, bastardizing the music as a lame lounge act where he
finally gets to front the band. He embodies the very thing that Eddie was
against – prostituting yourself instead of remaining true to the music. Sal’s
version of the Cruisers, complete with an Eddie wannabe, is like when you see
Lynyrd Skynyrd with only one original member of the band left – a pale
imitation of its former self.
Davidson
has said that the inspiration for the film came from a desire to "get all
my feelings about the music of the last 30 years of rock music into it.” He
optioned P.F. Kluge’s novel of the same name with his own money and at great
financial risk. He wrote the screenplay with Arlene Davidson and decided to use
a Citizen Kane-style story structure.
He said in an interview, “That was in my head: the search.” Along came Joe
Brooks, who penned the Debby Boone hit, “You Light Up My Life,” and offered
$125,000 to help produce the film but he wanted Rick Springfield to star as
Eddie. The filmmaker met the rock star but he wanted to cast an unknown. “People
want to believe it really existed. It can’t be Rick Springfield and the
Cruisers.”
Davidson
eventually made a deal with Time-Life, a company that was going into the
moviemaking business. However, they quickly exited the business after making
two films that were not financially successful and Davidson’s project was left
high and dry. He was understandably upset and a couple days later he went out
to dinner and ran into a secretary who worked on the first film he had made.
Davidson told her what had happened to his film and she gave his script for Eddie and the Cruisers to her business
partners. In a relatively short time a deal was struck with a company called
Aurora and Davidson was given a $6 million budget. Aurora made only three films
– The Secret of NIMH (1982), Heart Like a Wheel (1983), and his film.
For the
real-life band that would create the music Eddie and the Cruisers would play in
the film, Davidson talked to George Thorogood and the J. Geils Band. To get a
credible looking and sounding band for the film, Davidson hired Kenny Vance,
one of the original members of Jay and the Americans, and music supervisor for Animal House (1978). He showed Davidson
his scrapbook, the places they performed, the car they drove in, and things
like how they transported their instruments. Vance also told Davidson stories
about his band, some of which he incorporated into the script. Vance asked
Davidson to describe his fictious band and what their music sounded like.
Initially, he said that the Cruisers’ sound resembled Dion and the Belmonts but
when they meet Frank they had elements of Jim Morrison and The Doors.
Davidson,
however, did not want to lose sight of the fact that the Cruisers were
essentially a Jersey bar band and he thought of Bruce Springsteen and the E
Street Band. Davidson told Vance to find him someone that could produce music
that contained elements of those three bands. Davidson was getting close to rehearsals
when Vance called him and told him that he had found the band – John Cafferty
and the Beaver Brown Band from Providence, Rhode Island. Davidson met them and
realized that they closely resembled the band as described in the script, right
down to a black saxophone player, whom he actually cast in the film. Initially
Cafferty was hired to write a few songs for the film but he did such a good job
of capturing the feeling of the 1960s and the 1980s that Davidson asked him to
score the film.
Tom
Berenger did not try to learn how to play the piano for the film but did
practice keyboards for hours in his trailer to at least create the illusion
that he could play. Matthew Laurance actually learned how to play the bass
through rehearsals. Michael Pare said of his role in the film that it was
"a thrill I've never experienced. It's a really weird high. For a few
moments, you feel like a king, a god. It's scary, a dangerous feeling. If you
take it too seriously." Davidson had the actors who played in Eddie's band
rehearse as if they were getting ready for a real concert. Pare remembers,
"The first time we played together – as a band – was a college concert. An
odd thing happened. At first, the extras simply did what they were told. Then,
as the music heated up, so did the audience. They weren't play-acting anymore.
The screaming, stomping and applause became spontaneous.” Davidson recalls,
"One by one, kids began standing up in their seats, screaming and raising
their hands in rhythmic applause. A few girls made a dash for the stage,
tearing at Michael's shirt. We certainly hadn't told them to do that. But we
kept the cameras rolling.”
The
filmmakers do a decent job recreating the period details on a modest budget at
best. There’s the cool cars, the clothes, and so on, but more importantly there
is a tangible atmosphere of simpler times and nostalgia. This is encapsulated
in the straight-ahead rock ‘n’ roll music of the Cruisers that sounds a lot
like early Springsteen. There is also a little bit of period music, most
notably Del Shannon’s “Runaway,” that is used to immediately transport you back
to that time. As soon you hear that distinctive song it instantly invokes that
period and there is no question where we are.
What Eddie and the Cruisers nails so well is
the dynamic between the members in the band, like how Sal gets on Eddie’s
nerves, or how a romance develops between Frank and Joann Carlino (Helen
Schneider), the band’s back-up singer. Davidson’s film shows how the band
members bicker among each other but come together when it counts – playing
live, where they know how to energize an audience. The film presents several
band archetypes – the charismatic lead singer, the junkie band mate, the
arrogant one, the laid back one, and the thoughtful one – but without being too
obvious about it. Joann is the Patti Scialfa to Eddie’s Bruce Springsteen but
Frank falls for her the first time they meet in ’62. There are certainly sparks
between them but as anyone who’s been in a band knows, the fastest way to break
one up is getting romantically involved with a fellow bandmate.
One of
the best scenes in the film that illustrates the band’s dynamic is the
flashback showing how their biggest hit, “On the Dark Side,” evolved. Eddie
takes Frank’s slow ballad and spruces it up with a catchy up-tempo keyboard
melody. Pretty soon the rest of the band joins and a hit is born. This scene
shows what a great team Eddie and Frank are – the former supplies the music and
the latter supplies the words. It also shows Eddie’s uncanny ear for what works
in a song.
Michael
Pare really sells the music well and delivers just the right amount of energy
and charisma. It helps that the vocals he’s lip-synching to fit him well. You
almost believe that he’s really singing. Pare also portrays Eddie as
tantalizingly elusive and enigmatic. You are never quite sure what he’s
thinking and he’s a man of few words but clearly has ambitions above and beyond
entertaining an audience. With the album A
Season in Hell, Eddie wanted to create something different and when the
powers that be tried to deny him, he disappeared. According to both Davidson
and Pare, the former was tough on the latter during rehearsals. Pare remembers
him saying, “If you fuck up tomorrow, you’re fired.” If the actor didn’t do a
good job, Davidson wouldn’t have a film. This treatment continued during filming.
When it came to film the scene where Eddie takes the stage after learning a
bandmate has died, he had to break down. Davidson remembers:
“We had
500 extras standing around, and Michael was having a hard time finding it. I
used the situation to bring him to tears. I battered him to the point I’ve
never battered an actor in my life. To the point it was almost too unkind. But
when it was over, we hugged, and I knew I had a scene which would work in the
movie.”
Along
with Streets of Fire (1984), Eddie and the Cruisers was supposed to
make Pare a big movie star but both films tanked commercially and critically.
Now, he’s relegated mostly to direct-to-home-video fare.
Tom
Berenger conveys a slightly sad, wistful vibe as Frank clearly misses the times
he had with the band. He has made peace with his lot in life. He’s no longer a
musician and his ambitions died alongside Eddie. I always liked Berenger and
he’s wonderfully understated in this film. He would go on to the role of a
lifetime in Platoon (1986), which was
the antithesis to his role in Eddie and
the Cruisers and showcased his versatility as an actor. Prior to this film,
he also had a memorable turn in The Big
Chill (1983). For a while it looked like he would be leading man material
but he has settled rather nicely into character actor roles.
A young
Ellen Barkin plays the persistent reporter who tries to unravel the mystery of
Eddie’s death. She looks so young and beautiful in this film but isn’t given
too much screen time. Looking back, she had a pretty fantastic run in the 1980s
with this film, The Adventures of
Buckaroo Banzai Across the 8th Dimension (1984), The Big Easy (1987), and ended the decade in style with Sea of Love (1989). Unfortunately, she
did not have a good experience making the film, remarking in an interview,
"I think people were all fucked-up on drugs. I don't know. I was a little
removed, because I wasn't on the movie the whole time, but it seemed like it
was just a mess." Joe Pantoliano plays the Cruisers’ manager with the same
kind of enthusiasm that he would display in other memorable roles in the 1980s,
like Risky Business (1983), The Mean Season (1985), and Midnight Run (1988).
Eddie and the Cruisers was originally
intended to open during the summer but a scheduling error resulted in a
September release when its target audience – teenagers – were back in school.
It was released on September 23, 1983 and grossed $1.4 million on its opening
weekend. The film was pulled from theaters after three weeks and the ads were
pulled after one week. It would go on to make a disappointing $4.7 million in
North America.
Eddie and the Cruisers received largely mixed
to negative reviews. Film critic Roger Ebert gave the film two out of four
stars and found the ending “so frustrating, so dumb, so unsatisfactory, that it
gives a bad reputation to the whole movie.” In her review for The New York Times, Janet Maslin wrote,
"Some of the details ring uncannily true, like the slick oldies nightclub
act that one of the Cruisers is still doing nearly 20 years after Eddie's
supposed death. Other aspects of the movie are inexplicably wrong. Eddie's
music sounds good, but it also sounds a lot like Bruce Springsteen’s, and it
would not have been the rage in 1963.” However, she did praise Pare's
performance: "Mr. Pare makes a fine debut; he captures the manner of a
hot-blooded young rocker with great conviction, and his lip-synching is almost
perfect.” Gary Arnold, in the Washington
Post, wrote, "At any rate, it seemed to me that what Eddie and the Cruisers aspired to do was
certainly worth doing. The problem is that it finally lacks the storytelling
resources to tell enough of an intriguing story about a musical mystery man.”
In 1984, Eddie and the Cruisers found new life on
HBO. After the soundtrack album suddenly climbed the charts, the studio
re-released it in the fall of 1984. During its play dates on HBO, the album
sold three million copies. Nine months after the film opened, “On the Dark
Side,” the Cruisers big hit in the film, was the number one song in the
country. Embassy Pictures re-released the film for one-week based on successful
summer cable screenings and popular radio single but it failed to perform at
the box office. The film and the album eventually did well enough to make way
for a sequel – Eddie and the Cruisers II:
Eddie Lives (1989) – that saw Eddie as a construction worker in Montreal
(?!). Davidson was offered the sequel but was not crazy about the idea and
wanted no part of it. With the exception of Pare, Laurance and Cafferty, nobody
from the first film had anything to do with it and the less said about this
awful film the better. After the commercial failure of the first film, Davidson
has continued to work steadily, mostly in television, directing episodes of Law & Order, Picket Fences, Chicago Hope
and Judging Amy but has been inactive
since 2002.
It’s
interesting that the initial rise and fall of Eddie and the Cruisers mirrors the arc of President Kennedy. The
band peaks during his presidency and Eddie disappears and his band breaks up
after Kennedy is assassinated and the country was thrown into turmoil and
disillusionment. This parallel seems more than just a coincidence so I’m sure
Davidson had it mind when he wrote the screenplay. What is so endearing about Eddie and the Cruisers is the idealism
that permeates the film as embodied by Eddie’s desire to create songs that will
allow him “to fold ourselves up in them forever,” as he tells Frank at one
point. The film has an internal conscience and celebrates the notion that music
can take you to another place and make you forget about your daily problems for
a few minutes. This is tempered by a melancholic tone that permeates the scenes
that take place in the present. Eddie’s death and the end of the Cruisers hangs
like a heavy cloud over the surviving members and all the old feelings and
memories are dredged up thanks to Maggie’s inquiries.
Eddie and the Cruisers celebrates getting
lost in the music and how it makes you feel. This is ambitious stuff for a
little a film about a reclusive singer for a bar band. For the most part, the
film pulls it off. Along with Almost
Famous (2000) and Hard Core Logo
(1996), it is definitely one of my favorite films about a fictious band.
Davidson is still proud of his film but is bitter about how it was handled.
“That picture should have been a theatrical success. There was an audience for
it. People still watch it and still tell me about it.” Eddie and the Cruisers has aged surprisingly well and over time all
the good notes are intact.
SOURCES
Edgers,
Jeff. “Eddie and the Cruisers was a massive
‘80s Flop. How did it become a beloved cult film?” Washington Post.
April 24, 2015.
Fragoso,
Sam. "Ellen Barkin on Great Directors and Her Favorite Roles, from Diner to Buckaroo Banzai." The A.V. Club. March 14, 2015.
Muir,
John Kenneth. The Rock and Roll Film
Encyclopedia. Applause Theatre & Cinema Books. 2007.